Weekly civic intelligence report · v2.2
Trump's surgeon general nominee touts organics, questions vaccines, and discusses spirituality on podcasts. This represents concerning public health messaging from a nominee.
A-score: Personnel_capture mechanism active (surgeon general nominee with anti-vaccine views). Capture scores 4 (institutional credibility threat to public health apparatus). Civil_rights 2 (indirect public health access concerns). Mechanism modifier 1.3 for personnel_capture, scope 1.2 for federal/broad. Severity: durability 1.1 (Senate confirmation could entrench), reversibility 1.0 (removable), precedent 1.1 (normalizes anti-science in health leadership). Final A: 18.67. B-score: High outrage_bait (8) - vaccine skepticism from health official is inflammatory. Media_friendliness (8) - simple narrative, podcast quotes. Meme_ability (6) - quotable anti-vax statements. Layer2: mismatch (8) - surgeon general should promote vaccines, not question them. Pattern_match (7) - fits Trump administration controversy template. Timing (6) - nomination period. Low intentionality (4) - pre-existing podcast content surfaced by media. Final B: 26.08. D-score: -7.41. List B classification: B>=25 AND D<=-7.41.
Monitor for actual policy implementation if confirmed. Track Senate confirmation hearing testimony on vaccine stance. Distinguish between nominee's personal podcast musings versus official public health policy positions if appointed. Real constitutional damage occurs only if anti-vaccine messaging becomes official surgeon general guidance affecting federal health programs.